Skip to main content
Journal
Information Fusion
Year of Publication
2026
Status
Published
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.inffus.2026.104977
ISSN Number
1566-2535
Number of Pages
104977
Volume
140
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly organizes information, facilitates communication, and develops proposals in conflict management. How these interventions compare with human-delivered third-party intervention remains unclear. We systematically reviewed 138 quantitative reports on negotiation, conflict-related reconciliation, and group discussion available by 1 September 2026. Using three-level random-effects models with CR2 cluster-robust inference, we analyzed 261 effects from 51 distinct reports and expressed pooled estimates as r-equivalents. Intervention-related differences and associations were synthesized separately by their original comparison types and adjustment conditions, while within-study AI–human comparisons formed a distinct synthesis. Unadjusted comparisons yielded positive average estimates across the source-specific syntheses, whereas covariate-adjusted condition comparisons were imprecise. Within-study AI–human comparisons yielded a positive pooled difference across the outcomes assessed (r=0.155, 95% CI [0.103, 0.206]; 7 reports, 27 effects). This confidence interval remained above zero after individual report omissions or removal of comparative-preference measures, although the prediction interval included zero. The large language model (LLM) subgroup yielded r=0.156 (95% CI [0.048, 0.261]; 3 reports, 14 effects), but its confidence intervals included zero after each individual report omission. Moderator tests for contextual, intervention, and study characteristics were not significant after Holm correction. In individual studies, comparisons of intervention strategies suggested that relative performance varied across outcomes. The pooled AI–human difference combines content evaluations with behavioral and decision measures and does not establish an AI advantage in real-world conflict resolution. AI–human comparisons should therefore distinguish who generates, selects, and delivers advice and assess outcomes relevant to these functions. Such comparisons are particularly needed in organizational conflicts, where evidence remains limited.

Important information

Rejestr Instytutów Naukowych: RIN-IV-3/98

NIP: 631-011-22-45

REGON: 000564702

Skrytka ePUAP: /IITISPAN/SkrytkaESP

e-doręczenia: AE:PL-33995-65265-VDDUI-33

PIC (Participant Identification Code): 951424501

Contact us

Institute location:

ul. Bałtycka 5
44-100 Gliwice

Telephone numbers:

  • +48 32 231 73 19
  • +48 32 231 71 50
  • +48 32 330 23 89

E-mail address: office@iitis.pl